The three argumenteers

Posted on March 23rd, 2011 by Sacha Chua

(Or arguers, more correctly? But Argumenteers is a fun little reference.)

Logos, ethos, and pathos. =) W- and I would like to help J-, her friends, and other people learn more about critical thinking, rhetoric, argument, and eventually negotiation. Someday I may even make a kid’s book about arguments so that kids (and grown-ups!) can get better at recognizing, identifying, and responding to arguments. First step: pick up more practice ourselves.

The sequence we might work with is:

identify and break down arguments
classify arguments
identify fallacies and respond to them
identify figures of speech and rhetorical effect
repair and respond to stronger arguments

So I’m going to try reading the opinion pages of the New York Times and other news sources and analyzing the arguments there. First up: Teaching to the Text Message, Andy Seslsberg, March 19, 2011.

Argument: Short, Internet-focused writing assignments may be more effective than long writing assignments early in the college curriculum.

1. Long assignments don’t work.
1.1. Support: I’ve been teaching with long writing assignments for years, [so I know what I’m talking about.]
1.2 Support: Students’ long writing assignments are of low quality (“font-size manipulation, plagiarism, cliches”).
1.3 Implied: Teachers don’t have the time to check long writing assignments in depth.
2. Implied: Short Internet-focused writing assignments will be more interesting and more useful.
2.1 Support: Alternative formats get people interested.
2.2 Support: Real-life contexts for communication such as networking e-mails, tweets, or comments will be more relevant to students than essays or book reports.
2.3 Support: Alternative assignments are more like students’ everyday life.
2.4 Support: Writing concisely is useful and more in tune with the world’s needs.
2.5 Support: Great thinkers can pack a lot of thought into a few words. [Therefore students won’t be missing out, and there might be useful ways to connect the lessons to past thinkers.]
3. Support: Short assignments can help students develop better skills and teachers give better feedback.
3.1. Support: Short assignments force clarity and reduce waste.
3.2. Support: Teachers can give short assignments more individual attention. [Implied: More individual attention can help students learn more effectively]
3.3. Support: Short writing assignments encourage conciseness and creativity
3.4 Support: Moderation – colleges can still have long writing assignments later in the curriculum.

Hmm… There must be lots of ways to make rhetoric and argument fun and interesting…

More posts about: argument, rhetoric, sketches // Add Comment »

Short URL: http://sachachua.com/blog/p/22170

On This Day...

2013: Weekly review: Week ending March 22, 2013 — Lots and lots of drawing this week. =) Sketchnoted a conference, made a print, had lots of fun. Blog [...]
2012: Ice cream season and the first seeds in the garden — It’s unseasonably warm by all accounts. The historic average for the next fourteen days is a high of 7C and [...]
2010: Presentation kaizen: Seven everyday ways to become a better presenter — Talk given at PresentationCamp. Presentation Kaizen View more presentations from Sacha Chua You need to have something worth presenting. Shortest [...]
2010: How to brain-dump what you know — Why You’re going to need it. Why solve things twice? Write things down. You can save yourself the time it [...]
2009: Drupal tip: Test mail sending with Devel — If you don’t want to send lots of mail to your users when you’re testing your site, change the Devel [...]
2009: Outsourcing processes: Wake-up call — Here’s my process for my wake-up call: Every day, at the wake-up time I specified, please: Go to start.sachachua.com and sign in. Sign [...]
2009: Wake up calls — I’m beginning to rather like wake-up calls. I set up a recurring task in Timesvr to have someone call me at [...]
2007: Blogging: not just for extroverts — In the middle of my enthusiastic bubbling-over about IBM’s social software offerings, Hossam Ali-Hassan asked me, “Do bloggers tend to [...]
2007: The magic of connection — There are many business reasons why social bookmarking makes sense, but let me tell you a personal story to show you [...]
2007: It’s spring — Now I can believe that it’s spring. The sunlight is warm against my back. The sun gazes on me and I [...]
2006: When it rains, it pours — Today (Thursday) is the area-level Toastmasters international speech contest. I don’t feel prepared for it at all. Unlike the other [...]
2005: Traffic — Nagje-jaywalk na suso Nakita ko sa Quiapo Kay bilis nyang tumakbo Naunahan pa ako Thanks to Clair for getting tanaga into my head (I [...]
2005: Microfinancing — Read technobiography: OT: Jun-jun the Parking Man and think about the poor. I think microfinancing is a good idea, BUT it [...]
2005: How to hire great people — joelonsoftware has interesting insights on hiring the best people. He pokes holes in hiring fallacies like super-selection: “We’re so good we [...]
2005: Wheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee! — Hi Sacha, I just talked to the grad office. They were waiting for me to give my approval, oops. :) An offer [...]
2004: MIT application — Deleted: Lost secret key.
2004: Stanford: Stream data manager — http://www-db.stanford.edu/stream/index.html In applications such as network monitoring, telecommunications data management, web personalization, manufacturing, sensor networks, and others, data takes the form of continuous [...]
2004: Using tla for archives — Look! I’m being used as an example! http://tkd.kicks-ass.net/planner/GnuArch.html That’s it, I’ve got to check out this checksumming thing… My name is [...]
2004: Information retrieval course — http://www.csee.umbc.edu/~ian/irS01/ ../../notebook/plans/2004.03.23
2004: School Bus — It’s not much, but if I don’t force myself to write, I might never get around to it. =) She glanced at [...]
2004: cal-desk-calendar support for planner-diary.el — Travis B. Hartwell wrote: Hi all, I patched what I hope is the most recent version of planner-diary.el from tla to optionally utilize [...]
2003: harvey chua — My mom wants to make sure her friends find her e-mail and our website. Harvey Chua
2003: custom binding — I have bound keycode 131 to ( and keycode 129 to ) on my jp106 keyboard. 131 is the muhenkan [...]
2003: deleting messages after N days — tips — I was somewhat apologetic about the lack of delete-after-N-days features in Linux mail clients, since my mom relies on that to [...]

sacha chua living an awesome life