Visual book review: Critical Inquiry: The Process of Argument

Posted on March 20th, 2012 by Sacha Chua

I first read this book in October 2010 while scrambling to learn as much as I could about communication and rhetoric in preparation for marriage. Since then, there have been zero household arguments, which is not a bad thing. Fortunately, the Internet, newspapers, and books provide a steady stream of logical fallacies that let me exercise the skills I picked up from this book.

The insight that stuck with me from this book was that you should repair holes in your opponents’ arguments—argue their case more strongly than they did—before demolishing the strengthened arguments. People rarely do this, but I’ve seen a couple of good examples on the political/feminist blogs I read.

It reminds me of what we need to do in order to help people deal with their concerns to new ideas or technologies. It’s not enough to fight against straw-man arguments. You may need to be more concerned about people’s concerns than they are, before you can help them find a way forward.

Critical Inquiry: The Process of Argument
Michael Boylan (Westview Press: 2009) – ISBN 978-0813344522

See other visual book notes!

More posts about: argument, book, communication, reading, visual, visual-book-notes // 2 Comments »

Short URL: http://sachachua.com/blog/p/23229

Joel

Love the shadow on the magnifying glass!
http://sachachua.com Sacha Chua

Joel: See, I’m working on drawing better… =)

On This Day...

2013: Quantified Awesome feedback — I just realized that my feedback form on Quantified Awesome didn’t let people fill in their e-mail addresses, and people [...]
2011: Weekly review: Week ending March 18, 2011 — From last week’s plans Work [X] Work on critsit involving AJAX and PHP [-] Deploy web services onto Websphere [...]
2010: Coaching people on how to give better remote presentations – Thinking out loud — We need better web presentations. There are so many opportunities out there. I think I can help more people learn [...]
2007: Sweet, caching works — Caching makes my search engine relatively responsive. Yay. I might just be able to make a decent prototype after all… Random Emacs [...]
2007: Argh, deliveries — So the books I ordered from Amazon are here, but the DHL person couldn’t drop them off this morning because no [...]
2006: Tango party and stuff — I visited the hospital again. Lasagna is apparently not a good idea as it gets cold pretty quickly, and it depends [...]
2006: Well-spent Sunday — I baked chocolate chip cookies for my hospital-bound friend today, and we had a lot of fun at an impromptu party [...]
2005: Turning my mind to money — “What? Sacha’s going mercenary?” No, I’m still very much into free software and I’m still definitely not going for easy-money stuff like [...]
2005: Business book: You Can Negotiate Anything — Today I finished reading Herb Cohen’s You Can Negotiate Anything: How to Get What You Want. Its main points were: Almost everything [...]
2003: scrabble game — Just finished two games of Scrabble. The first I played with Mom and my sister Kathy. Mom nearly outscored me [...]
2003: emacs-wiki and automatic publishing — I use this nifty LISP snippet to automatically publish my pages whenever I save. (add-hook 'emacs-wiki-mode-hook (lambda () (add-hook 'after-save-hook (lambda [...]
2003: trend summer outing — Probably won’t accept invitation. Feel completely lazy and am thinking of staying home and playing Scrabble. Besides, shouldn’t make other [...]
2003: dear_raed blog: stories from within Iraq — http://dear_raed.blogspot.com/ is an interesting blog that gives you a feel of what it’s like in Iraq.

sacha chua living an awesome life