Strangers talking to us
| parentingA- will probably be strongly influenced by how I interact with people, so it's good to give that some thought. I am a bit reserved, and I'm sometimes reflexively suspicious of strangers who talk to me out of the blue. I've been making an effort to smile at people and engage in the usual chitchat about the weather. There are certain things that get the conversation off on the wrong foot and I haven't quite figured out how I want to handle them. Let me think about what I like and don't like, and what I want to try next.
Let's start with positive stuff, so I don't feel like such a curmudgeon. What I like about the way strangers sometimes interact with A- and me:
- Observation: “You seem to really like digging!”
- Offering: “Would you like to play with this?”
- Joining in: Impromptu dance party
- Recognition: “You did it!” “That looks like fun!”
- Inviting A- to make contact: extending a hand for a high five or a fist bump, but not making it awkward or insistent.
- Empathizing
Things I don't like:
People just reaching out and touching A-! This makes me want to back off or swat their hand away. I understand that baby skin looks so soft and inviting, and I get that people want kiddos to pay attention to them, but this just creeps me out. I'm tempted to experiment with stroking them right back and seeing how weird that makes them feel, but that just prolongs the interaction. So far, I'm getting better at saying, “Please don't touch.” Some people really don't get the hint, though. I may have to practice saying stronger variants.
What's the harm? Nothing much, I guess, but I want A- to learn about bodily autonomy both ways (her body is her own, and other people's bodies are theirs), and it creeps me out that other people want to satisfy their curiosity by touching people, and it's supposed to be okay just because they're touching a kid. Uh, no.
I am, however, totally okay with people crouching down to her level, saying something like “Would you like a high five?”, extending their hand, and waiting for her to respond.
I also cut little kids some slack, although I'll still wave them off if I'm in arms' reach. Just because someone wants to hug or kiss or touch someone doesn't mean that person has to be hugged or touched or kissed. I'm getting better at intervening with something like “Wait, please. A-, it looks like ____ would like to give you a hug. Would you like to hug or wave hello?”
What's wrong with her eye? Another one for dealing with other people's curiosity. There was a Holland-Bloorview ad that resonated with me. It said: “Asking is better than assuming. But do you really need to know?” When I feel relaxed, I say things like, “She was born that way. It doesn't hurt, though, and she can see fine with her other eye.” I might also practice saying “Why do you ask?” and when people say, “Just curious,” going with “I don't feel like satisfying your curiosity right now.” Or maybe “Why do you need to know?” said with a smile.
And then there are playful approaches: “She lost it in a hockey fight!” “She's a pirate in training.” “Aaaaah! Did it fall out again?”
There's also “Isn't it amazing how we can adapt to situations? A- can see just fine with her other eye. She can also hear just fine too, so let's include her in the conversation!”
Or maybe that old standby, “Would you like to ask her? It's up to her if she wants to answer or not, of course!”
How cute! Or “What a cutie,” or other variants that focus on appearance. I understand that that's many people's default compliment for kids (especially girls). People are usually quite genial, so I'll try to be gracious about it. It might be fun experimenting with playfully asking A- if she wants to be cute today or a more interesting adjective. “Cute” kinda feels a little dismissive, limiting, and more focused on the eye of the beholder, and it tends to have an expiration date… I wonder if “Are you a cute little baby today or an awesome big kid” sets up too much of a contrast. “Cute is out, awesome is in.” might be too conceptual. “Baby sheep are cute. A- isn't just cute, she's awesome! Speaking of cute sheep, there's a new lamb at Riverdale Farm! Have you been?”, maybe? Long thing to say, but redirects the conversation…
I'm okay with A- getting compliments, and I hope she doesn't get a complex about her appearance. “Cute” is just a bit weird, though, or maybe I'm just a bit weird about it. :)
Boy or girl? I'm guessing people don't want to make the mistake of assuming gender, but aren't used to avoiding gendered pronouns. I guess I could jump straight to introducing A- by name and interest, since A- has a gendered name. Then it would feel less like her gender is the first thing people need to know about her.
How old is she? People are probably just calibrating their age guesses and figuring out how impressed they should be with whatever A-‘s doing. Maybe I'll practice poking them ever so slightly back. “You first! How old are you?” Or maybe directing people to ask her instead (answers optional), so she gets practice in conversations.
Are you from China? Maybe people are trying to calibrate their race guesser? I get this occasionally from non-Asians awkwardly making conversation. Filipinos tend to think I'm Chinese too, but generally don't mention it until I say something in Tagalog that prompts an “Ah! Akala ko Intsik ka” from them. Maybe I'll practice the Southern “What a thing to say.” Or maybe “You first! Are you from ___?”
Ooh. This Citylab post has a fun idea for dealing with the “Where are you from?” question: “Mars!” This post gives me a more positive view of why people might ask. Maybe I could distract and redirect with “Isn't it wonderful how Toronto is such a diverse city and anyone can be a Canadian? Where are you from?” Or maybe “It's fun to guess where people are from. Are you from ____?”
Ideas to play with!
2 comments
daviding
2018-04-14T20:32:40ZDifferent cultures have different senses of personal distance, https://en.m.wikipedia.org/... . These are learned at a very early age, and are difficult to change.
I was brought up in the only Chinese family in a town of 3000 (Gravenhurst), and our family is not one of huggers. Personal distance for me is actually relatively far. When I got my American-Italian-Polish foster relatives in suburban Chicago, I had to learn to hug them. After 2 years, it became natural, but the first time I came back after moving away for a long time, there was a funny encounter because the teenage daughter came over to hug me and bounced off, because I wasn't expecting it. Then there was my Jewish-American housemate who put his hand on my shoulder when I was focused on studying. There was a good laugh because he said I really jumped, and we knew that the cultural differences were really deep.
However, in Gravenhurst, everybody knows everybody else, or at least the family or social circle you're associated with. Violent crime is practically nonexistent, so everyone is friendly, even to people they don't know. When my fiancee now wife moved from Vancouver to Gravenhurst for a short time, she couldn't get used to how everybody knows about everything in everyone's life, like there's no privacy. That's big city suspicion versus small town passing of time. When we visit friends in small town Iowa and Kentucky, I know that we're the subject of conversation for a while. Nothing changes much in small towns, so passers through are fair game for entertainment.
My mother loved to talk to children after she moved to the big city. It never occurred to her why big city people are so cold. I see myself as socially friendly towards strangers, but still I am physically distant. My sons are city street smart but friendly, and are more comfortable at hugging, coming down through their mother's side. In multicultural Toronto, they know how to do the hugs and handshakes of a variety of subcultures.
sachac
2018-04-15T02:15:59ZHmmm... I think I'm mostly working on figuring my own hang-ups and what to do about them: which parts to keep for now, which parts to experiment with.
I'm a little conscious about things like:
- gendered interactions ("What a cute little girl"),
- autonomy and authenticity (people touching kids, people making kids hug and kiss others, people making kids say sorry),
- focusing on process and growth ("You're so smart!" versus "You worked hard on that!")
- and, because A- is visually different, stuff that makes her feel like an other ("What's wrong with her eye?").
She'll learn more from my graceful handling of situations (and post-conversation debriefing) than strangers will from attempts to nudge them towards different ways of interacting, although it would be neat to find tactful, positive ways to do both by inviting people to think about it and explore the possibilities.
I'm learning so much about talking to kids, and I've got a reason to do so. It's totally understandable that people might not have thought about these things and are responding the way most people do. Besides, I'm not even certain the things I'm trying are the Right Way. I'm curious about them as experiments, though, so it's up to me to figure out how to neatly fit these experiments into the flow of conversations so that people feel good as much as possible.
I've never been in a small-town environment. I wonder what that would feel like. Maybe that would counteract the way I grew up being a little suspicious of people approaching us (lots of scammers and harrassers in Manila). I wonder if I can tap into a small-town vibe in a big city with sufficient effort...
It would be interesting to model cultural flexibility with A-. I don't mind being the slightly odd person who explicitly checks if someone is feeling like hugging/waving/cheek-kissing and helps find the intersection of what both people feel like at the moment. I notice I pay attention to shifting needs for personal space (very dynamic, especially when kids are playing), so that's something too. Lots of things to explore!